How we rate workout tracker apps
We make Lift. We rate every app, including ours, by the same published criteria.
We make Lift, so we wrote the rules down before scoring anything, and we apply them to Lift exactly as we apply them to every other app.
The ground rules
- Official sources only. Facts come from the developer's own website, help center, or official App Store and Google Play listing. We do not use review sites, forums or our own guesses.
- Documented or it does not count. An app gets credit for a feature only if its developer documents it. When we could not find something, the page says "Not documented". That means we could not confirm it, not that the app lacks it.
- US prices, as listed. We use the price the developer states on its own pages where it gives one, otherwise the US store listing. Several developers say prices vary by region.
- Same rubric for everyone. Seven criteria, 1 to 5 points each, equal weight, 35 points maximum. No bonus points and no hidden adjustments.
- Store ratings are shown, not scored. Review counts differ by more than 100,000 times between these apps, and Lift has only a handful, so a star average would not compare like with like.
- Not scored when we cannot score it. If official material does not let us apply a criterion at all (for example, conflicting descriptions of a free plan), the app is listed as "checked, not scored" instead of getting a guessed number.
- No paid placement. No developer paid for, reviewed or approved these pages. We do not use affiliate links.
The seven criteria
Free plan
How much can you do without paying?
- 5: everything is free
- 4: unlimited logging and plans; only extras (charts, generators) are paid
- 3: unlimited logging, but routines or chart history are capped
- 2: tight caps (2 or fewer saved plans, or 14 days or less of history or stats)
- 1: no free plan (trial only)
Three-year cost
What is the cheapest official US price for full access over three years?
- 5: free, or $10 or less one-time
- 4: up to $50
- 3: up to $100
- 2: up to $200
- 1: more than $200
Platforms
Where can you use it?
- 5: iPhone and Android, with a watch app on both (or a web app)
- 4: iPhone and Android, with a watch app on one
- 3: iPhone and Android
- 2: one phone platform plus a watch
- 1: one platform only
Your data
Do you own your training log? One point each for: works offline, exports to a file, imports from another app, no account required. Score = points + 1.
- 5: all four
- 4: three
- 3: two
- 2: one
- 1: none documented
Programs and templates
How much help with what to do? (Scored on the full, paid product.)
- 5: a large library of named, established programs plus a custom builder
- 4: built-in programs or generated plans, plus templates
- 3: your own templates or routines only
- 2: limited routines
- 1: none
Progress tracking
One point each for: per-exercise charts, estimated 1RM, personal records, volume or muscle analytics, RPE or RIR logging. (Full product; minimum 1.)
- 5: all five
- 4: four
- 3: three
- 2: two
- 1: one or fewer
Ads and privacy
Will it show you ads or ask for an account?
- 5: documented no ads and no account required
- 4: no ads (documented, or no "Contains ads" label on Google Play); account required or not stated
- 3: says no ads, but its store privacy details list advertising data or tracking
- 2: ads in the free version
- 1: ads even for paying users
Why these criteria, and why equal weight
These cover what you live with after months of logging in an app, and what is hard to change once your history is in it: what happens to your history if you stop paying, whether you can leave with your data, whether the app works in a basement gym with no signal, and how much it really costs once the trial ends. Equal weight keeps us from tuning the formula toward any one app, including ours.
The weighting does favor some things over others, and you may weigh them differently. An app that charges yearly loses points on cost even if it is excellent; an app with no free plan loses points even if its paid plan is the best fit for you. That is why each roundup entry also says who the app is best for, and shows the reason behind every score.
Corrections
If a developer or reader shows us an official source that changes a fact, we update the page and the date. Write to support@zima-logistics.com.
See the scores: Best gym workout tracker apps.